Top Ingredients That Kill Nail Fungus (And What to Avoid)

You’ve tried creams.You’ve tried powders.You’ve tried prescriptions and even “natural” sprays.

But if the fungus is still there, the issue might not be your effort... it might be the ingredients.

Most antifungal products fail not because they don’t work at all — but because they don’t include the rightingredients, in the right combinations.

The truth is, toenail fungus is incredibly stubborn. It forms protective barriers (biofilms), hides deep in the nail bed, and thrives in weak, irritated skin.

That means your antifungal needs to be:

• Penetrating (not just surface-level)

• Multi-targeted (to avoid resistance)

• Safe for daily use on sensitive skin

Want a formula that combines all the best fungus-fighting ingredients into one simple oil blend? Click here to try Kerassentials ➔

In this post, we’ll break down:

• The qualities of truly effective antifungal ingredients

• The top natural oils and nutrients that kill fungus

• What to avoid (and why some ingredients actually make things worse)

• 
  

Let’s start with what makes an antifungal actually work.

What Makes a Good Antifungal Ingredient? (3 Critical Traits)

Toenail fungus doesn’t give up easily.

It hides under thick nails, forms protective biofilms, and adapts quickly to single-ingredient treatments. So for an antifungal to actually work, it needs more than just a label claim.

Here are the 3 things that make an ingredient genuinely effective:

1. It Must Penetrate the Nail Bed and Cuticle Fold

Fungus doesn’t just sit on top of the nail. It thrives underneath. A good antifungal must reach those deep layers to stop it at the source.

💡 Oils like tea tree and clove have been shown to permeate nail plates better than most creams or polishes.

2. It Needs Broad-Spectrum Activity (Against All Fungus Types)

Fungal infections can involve multiple strains: dermatophytes, yeast (candida), and molds. A great antifungal fights more than one.

💡 According to research in Medical Mycology, essential oils like lavender and undecylenic acid disrupt multiple fungal cell types and reduce resistance.

3. It Should Be Gentle Enough for Daily Use

Harsh chemicals may irritate skin, disrupt the microbiome, or dry out the nail fold — which makes reinfection easier.

💡 Natural oils that include skin-soothing agents like aloe, vitamin E, or flaxseed provide a healing base while killing fungus.

💡 | A review in Current Fungal Infection Reports found that multi-functional antifungals with anti-inflammatory and skin-supportive properties improve adherence and long-term outcomes (source).

Coming up next: the best natural ingredients that meet all three criteria — and what makes them so effective.

Top 7 Natural Ingredients That Kill Nail Fungus

When it comes to fighting toenail fungus, not all ingredients are created equal.

These 7 natural antifungal compounds have been studied for their ability to penetrate the nail, disrupt fungal growth, and soothe the surrounding skin:

✅ 1. Clove Bud Oil

• Rich in eugenol, a compound that breaks down fungal cell walls

• Disrupts biofilm formation and stops replication

• Known for both antifungal and anti-inflammatory effects

✅ 2. Tea Tree Oil

• Penetrates the nail plate deeply

• Kills dermatophytes (the most common cause of toenail fungus)

• Reduces swelling and irritation around the nail fold

  
  

✅ 3. Undecylenic Acid

• Derived from castor oil

• Proven effective against yeast, mold, and dermatophytes

• Works by weakening fungal cell membranes and stopping replication

✅ 4. Lavender Oil

• Antifungal and antibacterial

• Helps calm red, inflamed, or cracked skin

• Pairs well with other oils to enhance absorption

✅ 5. Aloe Vera

• Not directly antifungal, but helps soothe and hydrate damaged skin

• Supports healthy regrowth and barrier protection

✅ 6. DL-Alpha Tocopherol (Vitamin E)

• Antioxidant that protects skin cells from oxidative stress

• Helps heal cuticles and prevent cracking that allows reinfection

✅ 7. Flaxseed Oil

• Rich in omega-3s that calm inflammation and moisturize the nail fold

• Supports nail strength and flexibility during regrowth

💡 | According to a review in Frontiers in Pharmacology, essential oil combinations (like clove, tea tree, and lavender) outperform single-agent creams due to their synergistic effects and ability to reduce fungal resistance (source).

Next: ingredients to avoid — and why they may be doing more harm than good.

Ingredients to Avoid in Nail Fungus Treatments (And Why)

Some antifungal products may look promising — but they can actually do more harm than good.

Whether they dry out the skin, cause irritation, or lead to fungal resistance, these ingredients should be approached with caution:

❌ Alcohol-Based Sprays

• Can dry and crack the skin

• Weakens your natural barrier, allowing fungus to re-enter

• Doesn’t penetrate the nail bed effectively

❌ Formaldehyde or Toluene (in some nail polishes)

• Harsh solvents used in cosmetic products

• Can cause irritation, peeling, or allergic reactions

• Do not offer antifungal benefits and may worsen nail condition

❌ Single-Ingredient OTC Creams (like Clotrimazole)

• May work short-term, but fungi adapt quickly

• Don’t address biofilms or skin support

• Often lack moisturizing or soothing properties

❌ Fragrance or Artificial Dyes

• Common irritants found in cheap OTC blends

• Disrupt skin microbiome and increase inflammation

❌ Undisclosed “Proprietary Blends”

• Lack transparency

• You don’t know the actual concentrations or quality of active ingredients

💡 | According to Clinical Dermatology, common irritants and single-agent topical antifungals are associated with higher rates of recurrence due to poor skin tolerance and fungal resistance (source).

Let’s wrap up with a final recap, your next steps, and the #1 ingredient combo to look for in any fungus treatment.

Final Recap + Action Plan: Use Ingredients That Actually Work

You don’t have to keep guessing.

You don’t need to keep wasting time on products that irritate your skin or only work temporarily.

Now you know:

• What makes an antifungal ingredient truly effective

• Which natural oils are backed by science to fight fungus

• What to avoid if you want long-term healing

Your Next Steps:

• Choose multi-targeted ingredients that penetrate deeply

• Avoid harsh chemicals, mystery blends, and drying agents

• Support your skin barrier while fighting fungus consistently

Click here to try Kerassentials — the powerful oil blend made with clove, tea tree, lavender, and more to help kill fungus and support healthy nails naturally ➔

Want the full strategy to get rid of toenail fungus for good? Read: How to Get Rid of Toenail Fungus Naturally (The Ultimate Guide) ➔

This time, you don’t need to settle for surface-level fixes. Choose ingredients that go deeper — and finally give your nails the care they deserve.

About The Author: Jonathan Philips is a certified nutritionist and wellness expert with over a decade of experience helping individuals achieve vibrant health through natural strategies.

He is passionate about simplifying complex science into actionable advice that empowers people to take charge of their well-being.

When he’s not researching cutting-edge wellness breakthroughs, Jonathan enjoys hiking, exploring new healthy recipes, and promoting a balanced, holistic lifestyle.

Some of the links on this site are affiliate links, which means we may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase—at no additional cost to you.